Answer:

URL: okay | good | great | amazing| flawless | marry me!?

Theme: okay | good | great | amazing | flawless | marry me!?

Posts: okay | good | great | amazing | flawless | marry me!?

Icon: okay | good | great | amazing | flawless | marry me!?

Overall: okay | good | great | amazing | flawless | marry me!?

Am I Following?: yes| no | I am now!